Overall DateMySchool is a great website. It allows you to meet people from surrounding schools in your area, which I like because my school is small and I always see the same faces. You can block your own school, so that is good if you have privacy concerns like me haha .. It has a long list of privacy settings in place and allows you to narrow your searches efficiently. I have only met two people from the site thus far but both were a good experience. Really the only drawback is they sometimes suggest users to you whose profiles you are unable to view but this may be a glitch since according to the site they are still in the beta version. Their customer support is also good. I had a few questions about signing up and I received a response within 30 minutes on a weekend.
Pros
List of search/privacy features, great user experience, customer service, interesting conversation, reasonable pricing for premium stuff (although I did not upgrade), easy site navigation
Cons
No major cons in my experience
Visit DateMySchool Reviews about DateMySchool