I'm an ugly 46 year old man, and I actually got one response and one date off of this site from a girl that was local and was about ten years younger. That's a better result than I got from Plenty of Fish or OK Cupid, so I'm not ready to call it a scam.
Pros
Chance of responses.
Cons
Mostly for long distance.
Visit JapanCupid.com Reviews about JapanCupid.com